![]() |
|
IDT SD10 WS 1.4541-Graphit-St37-10-25-40-80-160 - Printable Version +- European Sealing Association (https://forum.bacibg.org) +-- Forum: Flange Gaskets (https://forum.bacibg.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: Gasket Database (https://forum.bacibg.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=2) +---- Forum: ESAData Approved Datasheets (https://forum.bacibg.org/forumdisplay.php?fid=10) +---- Thread: IDT SD10 WS 1.4541-Graphit-St37-10-25-40-80-160 (/showthread.php?tid=91) |
IDT SD10 WS 1.4541-Graphit-St37-10-25-40-80-160 - root - 01-06-2020 Approval of a new data sheet Type: spiralwound gasket Material: GR Testing lab: In-House RE: IDT SD10 WS 1.4541-Graphit-St37-10-25-40-80-160 - Teadit - 10-02-2020 Will abstain because I do not know how to vote. Like to add my comments. 1. agree with amtec on eg at 400degC and 2. PQR has a big tolerance (not too big) and at 500degC PQR is higher for 30-130MPa compared to lower temperature, which looks for me strange. Is the 500degC test done on another test rig? standard rig is limited to 400degC. RE: IDT SD10 WS 1.4541-Graphit-St37-10-25-40-80-160 - SGL - 10-02-2020 As it is a new data sheet, a cross check needs to be performed. For me PQR at 30 MPa at 500°C is most surprising, therefore I would vote for this test. RE: IDT SD10 WS 1.4541-Graphit-St37-10-25-40-80-160 - Donit - 10-07-2020 (10-02-2020, 09:53 AM)SGL Wrote: As it is a new data sheet, a cross check needs to be performed. For me PQR at 30 MPa at 500°C is most surprising, therefore I would vote for this test.Agree with this proposal. Leakage test at 160 bar is also a bit 'strange'. RE: IDT SD10 WS 1.4541-Graphit-St37-10-25-40-80-160 - Frenzelit - 10-13-2020 Results of PQR at 500°C obviously doesn't fit. Cross check especially for PQR 30 MPa 500°C required RE: IDT SD10 WS 1.4541-Graphit-St37-10-25-40-80-160 - Flexitallic - 10-13-2020 Cross check PQR @ 500 C at stresses 30, 50, 130, 200 MPa. RE: IDT SD10 WS 1.4541-Graphit-St37-10-25-40-80-160 - AMTEC - 10-19-2020 Cross-check: PQR @ 30 MPa/500 °C The PQR value determined in the cross-check is significant lower than the published value (0.75 vs. 0.87). In the repetition of the cross-check, the first was confirmed (0.75). IDT agreed to change PQR @ 30 MPa/500 °C to 0.75. In this case, all PQR appear consistent. The new value will be used in the final datasheet, it can be accepted now. |