Poll: Do you agree on publishing the data?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Yes
20.00%
1 20.00%
No (Comment in the thread)
20.00%
1 20.00%
Yes, but cross-check is required (Specify kind of test in the thread)
40.00%
2 40.00%
Abstain
20.00%
1 20.00%
Total 5 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
GORE® Universal Pipe Gasket 6.0mm
#1
Thumbs Up 
Approval of Data Import from gasketdata.org

Type: sheet gasket
Publication: 01/25/16

Material: PTFE

Link to gasketdata.org


Attached Files
.pdf   GORE®_STA-PURE(tm) Pipe Gaskets Style 1500_6,0_Vers 1_ESA Approval_2020-06-11.pdf (Size: 114.21 KB / Downloads: 11)
Reply
#2
Leakage at 40 bar (for unloading to 5 MPa the divergence in the measured leak rates is too high): ESAdata specification allows the following procedure in 5.4.2: "If a value (typically at the end of the graph, e. g. the 5 MPa unloading leakage value) is outside of the allowable divergency, one possibility to accept the rest of the values is to delete this value"
I spoke to Daniel Bissett (GORE). He would be fine with this approach. To make it look better it makes sense not only to delete the 5 MPa unloading value for QA 30, 40 and 80 MPa, but also for 60 MPa.
If these values are deleted, my vote changes from "no" to "yes".
Reply
#3
Double check on PQR Room Temperature 10MPa, because divergence is too big.
Reply
#4
All submitted GORE UPG show increase in leakage beginning at 60MPa rather than getting tighter. This might indicate destruction of gasket.I propose x check of qsmax RT with visual inspection of gasket.
Reply
#5
The following cross-check is recommended:

PQR at 10 MPa/RT

Comment to the other replies of the Task force:
Klinger: The increasing of the leak rate at gasket stress levels above 60 MPa is probably caused by too short measuring times. The characteristics are not influenced by this behavior.
SGL: During the unloading to 5 MPa a behaviour like a blow-out occurs. Gore is contacted to either delete these values or to adapt them to the higher leak rate of the double test. If the higher leak rates are used, the gasket characteristics are more or less identical.

Result of the cross-check is within the acceptable divergence range. Therefore the datasheet is accepted.


Attached Files
.pdf   GORE®_STA-PURE(tm) Pipe Gaskets Style 1500_6,0_Cross-check_2020-10-05.pdf (Size: 67.45 KB / Downloads: 3)
Reply
#6
I also suggest a cross-check PQR at RT/10 MPa...
Reply
#7
(06-22-2020, 02:07 PM)SGL Wrote: Leakage at 40 bar (for unloading to 5 MPa the divergence in the measured leak rates is too high): ESAdata specification allows the following procedure in 5.4.2: "If a value (typically at the end of the graph, e. g. the 5 MPa unloading leakage value) is outside of the allowable divergency, one possibility to accept the rest of the values is to delete this value"
I spoke to Daniel Bissett (GORE). He would be fine with this approach. To make it look better it makes sense not only to delete the 5 MPa unloading value for QA 30, 40 and 80 MPa, but also for 60 MPa.
If these values are deleted, my vote changes from "no" to "yes".

We studied the influence of the divergence in the leak rates during these unloading steps. We determined that a higher divergence has only a marginal influence on the characteristics, if the leak rate is increasing by a factor of 100 or more ("blow-out") compared to the leak rate in the previous gasket stress level.


Attached Files
.pdf   GORE®_STA-PURE(tm) Pipe Gaskets Style 1500_6,0_Comment on leak rates in unloading steps.pdf (Size: 75.61 KB / Downloads: 0)
Reply
#8
(09-30-2020, 03:58 PM)AMTEC Wrote: The following cross-check is recommended:

PQR at 10 MPa/RT

Comment to the other replies of the Task force:
Klinger: The increasing of the leak rate at gasket stress levels above 60 MPa is probably caused by too short measuring times. The characteristics are not influenced by this behavior.
SGL: During the unloading to 5 MPa a behaviour like a blow-out occurs. Gore is contacted to either delete these values or to adapt them to the higher leak rate of the double test. If the higher leak rates are used, the gasket characteristics are more or less identical.

Result of the cross-check is within the acceptable divergence range. Therefore the datasheet is accepted.
The cross-check test was requested because the difference between two tests was too high.
Now we have three results. 0.71; 0.78; 0.71 - I would say, that the Pqr value is 0.71 and not 0.75 as it is the mean value of first two tests. Value 0.78 seems to be too high.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)